I can't rate these shoes yet as I haven't used them yet. So my rating is really based on previous and current ASICS that I have. I can say that I have been wearing ASICS gel shoes for many years and they have always fitted well, provided good support and comfort. Out of the last 10 pairs I've owned I've had a pair that had a small issue and the problem was the upper back foam was sliding down and had to be adjusted from time to time.