Review on New Balance Running Gunmetal Seafoam Sports & Fitness by Charley Martinez

I've bought a pair of these in one color (Gunmetal) and so far the shoes fit well, are quite comfortable and have enough room in the toe box (I ordered half a size up). This shoe came in a New Balance box. I decided to buy another pair in the same style but in a different color (black). I ordered the same size and width but the black pair was too tight, had no room in the toe box and was uncomfortable to walk in. The black pair arrived in a standard Revain box. I suspect this pair was fake, or maybe I got a bad pair (factory defect?) because they don't feel like New Balance shoes should.