Size up for my daughter, she is tall and skinny for her age so I bought a size up, still short in the legs and very long in the crotch. There was also a small hole in one leg that leaked when she put them on. They are needed for a wedding, so we sew a hole and get by, the color is the same as the picture, and the fabric is nice and stretchy, warm fabric 3/5. I would try again to see if going up x 2 sizes makes a difference, but only because they aren't that expensive.
Amazon Essentials Little Short Sleeve Leotard Girls' Clothing for Active
61 Review
Thermajane Girl's Cozy and Comfy Thermal Underwear Long Johns Set with Fleece Lining
46 Review
C9 Champion Girls Supersoft Bright Girls' Clothing and Active
46 Review
Eocom Pairs Childrens Winter Animal Girls' Clothing
64 Review