I have just graduated from college and have been fortunate to have a recent professional job so I was in dire need of a professional wardrobe update. I didn't (and don't) have a lot of money, but I always think quality first because it's better to spend more money on a decent product than spend less money on something that will wear out quicker. However, this strap fits. I was specifically looking for a reversible belt with a DARK BROWN side to match the shoes I had already purchased. In addition to affordable quality, dark brown was the biggest requirement. If you are looking for a cheap, practical and attractive (dark brown or black) belt, feel free to buy it. See what other reviewers have to say about the feel the strap feels very durable. I don't want to repeat what you have already noted.