
It's some kind of silicone not rubber. They seem to work fine, but with one caveat. In particular, the small knob gaskets for the bolts don't hold in the bore nearly as well as the OEM ones. When I worked on it for a long time and put the covers back on to keep dust out of the engine, the button/bolt seals kept chipping off and falling to the floor. I ended up adding some RTV to keep them in place.

π§ FEL-PRO OS 30690 R Oil Pan Gasket Set: Reliable Seal for Optimal Performance
9 Review

RKX Vacuum Reseal Rebuild Gasket Replacement Parts
9 Review

5W-40FS A3/B4
24 Review

π§ Bapmic Engine Valve Cover with Gaskets & Bolts for BMW E82 E90 E70 128i 328i 528i X3 X5 Z4 (Part Number 11127552281)
9 Review