I've had item for a week now. In Chicago, snow is about 3 inches. Traction is good (pending surface YOU walk on) obviously you will have some slipping. The "waterproof'ness" seems to be ok, so far so good. I've walked in them during a slight rain and snowfall, feet have remained dry. My only one complaint (not a REAL complaint - my past boots have been worse, offering no warmth) I wish that these where warmer, however it is sufficient and take into consideration the current/soon to be temperature will be -25. Overall, I do not regret the purchase.