Appears to be good quality - I haven't worn it long enough to know for sure. The size of the belt is very relative and varies greatly depending on the brand. I think Florisheim is the right size (for comparison, the comfortable belts at Costco run a size larger than stated). Since the belt you are currently using can be any size on the accuracy scale, I would recommend trying a few sizes to find the right one.
🧲 Wurkin Stiffs Plastic Magnetic Men's Accessories and Collar Stays for Stiff N Stay
8 Review
👔 Revolutionize Your Style with Fashion Anchor Pack Collar Stays
8 Review
👔 Premium Plastic Collar Stays - Assorted Sizes in Crisp White Finish
9 Review
Stiffs Wurkin: Premium 👔 Assorted Brass Collar for Polished Style
9 Review