Review on Dog Training Bag: Treat Pouch For Small To Large Dogs, Tote Carry Kibble Snacks Toys, Metal Clip & Poop Bag Dispenser - Blue/Black by Melanie Hartmann

When I bought this product it said that it included a collapsable bowl and a training clicker. I don't care for the clicker, they have never worked for us in the past. But I thought the bowl would be cool to have. When we received it, it did not have either the clicker or the bowl. And now when I check the product listing, neither is showing as included. I thought maybe it was a different bag I had been looking at but viewing the questions and the reviews it does appear they used to be included and no longer are (just hadn't been updated when I made the purchase).Despite expecting those two things, everything else about this bag has been fantastic. It's great to have the option of the belt and the shoulder strap. It closes easily enough and has ample room for treats for training (we pair this with the pepperoni training treats cut in pieces for training our puppy). It's easy to clean, and comfortable to wear at the hip. The quality of the bag is much better than I was expecting for the price - thus the high rating even though it didn't include everything the product page said at the time.Overall I'd recommend this bag for the price and it has been working great for our family and our 5-month-old puppy!