I bought a size 0-2 for my 3 year old daughter (she wears 3t/4t clothes) and they fit perfectly with room to grow so I would definitely recommend going down a size.
However, we're very happy with it - her hands stayed warm and dry even when snow got into her boots and everywhere else.
Stay Cozy with Minus33 Merino Wool Midweight Gaiter - Perfect Cold Weather Girls' Accessory
49 Review
Gilbin Kids Magic-Stretch Gripper Gloves - Colorful Set of 6 Pairs
42 Review
CIKIShield 6 Pack Children Adjustable Cloth Face Mask: Washable, Reusable Face Cover for Kids - UV Protection Included
45 Review
Bememo 4 Pairs Fingerless Gloves Half Finger Mittens Solid Color Knitted Typing Gloves for Boys and Girls, Ideal for Winter
42 Review
2-Pack Neck Gaiter Face Cover with Filters, Ideal for Outdoor Activities, Durable Washable & Reusable
32 Review
Stylish and Reusable Washable Balaclava: Perfect Fashion Scarf Accessory for Girls
24 Review
Bazzle Baby BandoBib: Stylish and Adjustable Girls' Accessory with Double Layers
34 Review
MANSHU Women Soft Scarf Shawl Girls' Accessories in Fashion Scarves
34 Review