Review on 🖤 Peripera Ink Black Mascara - Volumizing, Lengthening, Thickening, Waterproof, Smudgeproof, Long-lasting, Not Tested on Animals - Volume Curling (#02), 0.24 fl oz by Courtney Wang

Pros and cons - never comes off. Love it, my second purchase, got the brown earlier when the black was sold out but love the black even more. I was immediately surprised that it is so difficult to wash off. The best way I've found is with oil, a damp cloth, and patience. I don't use it everyday when I'm at home as it's not easy to wash off, I save it for weekends/occasions/going out. I swim in the sea with it several times a week and it doesn't smudge and my lashes look the same before and after. IMO looks better in person than in the pictures