Zero stars for the price. Poor quality belt and material. I am ordering in 2 different colors and was shocked at how fragile the leather seemed. The buckle on my mahogany belt came out of the box with a chipped finish. My guess is that it was either returned and resold, or the workmanship was poor and it was damaged during shipping. The quality of the leather is poor and seriously resembles leather vinyl. I am shocked that AE is selling this as leather. I am very disappointed in Allen Edmonds as they usually have high quality products. I have over 10 pairs of their shoes, belts and bags and this is by far the worst quality product I have ever bought from them. I personally bought this belt because it was the only belt they offered in mahogany color that matched my mahogany shoes. However, the color looks black and you can barely tell it's brown even if you shine a light on it. Please save your time and don't buy this belt. AE lost some of my respect with this sale. For something in a similar price range, buy the AE Manistee belt, which is much more premium than this one. For something of similar quality, you can spend $25 at Marshalls and find something better.