I'm not entirely sure if it's real leather, but it feels similar and hasn't fallen apart on me, so it fits me. It's rigid, but not to the point that it can't be bent.
40 Metal Collar Stays Box
9 Review
𧲠Wurkin Stiffs Plastic Magnetic Men's Accessories and Collar Stays for Stiff N Stay
8 Review
Stiffs Wurkin: Premium π Assorted Brass Collar for Polished Style
9 Review
π Ultimate Flexibility with Premium Extender Expandable Elastic America Men's Accessories
9 Review