It was the second. They last a long time and look good with any pants. The black color comes from a shiny coat over a fabric belt. If you pull the belt a little harder over time, part of the belt will rub against the metal buckle and the black coating will peel off, leaving an unsightly gray fabric underneath. Be careful how you tighten it.
220 Plastic π Collar Stays for Organized Closet
9 Review
π Premium Plastic Collar Stays - Assorted Sizes in Crisp White Finish
9 Review
Stiffs Wurkin: Premium π Assorted Brass Collar for Polished Style
9 Review
𧲠Wurkin Stiffs Plastic Magnetic Men's Accessories and Collar Stays for Stiff N Stay
8 Review