I bought this set and the more expensive one with less comparable items and gifts for my girls. I assumed it would be of lower quality because I got more items for a lower price but I was wrong and ended up just wasting my money on another one. My 5 year old daughter didn't realize it was fake makeup (I thought she did) and used it all day before realizing the color wasn't actually on her skin. So I can say without a doubt it looks plausible. Since this one has more parts, they tend to be drawn to it rather than the other. I'm deducting a star because the colored part of the lipstick fell out of the lipstick base within the first two weeks of play. It's easy to fix, so it's not the end of the world, and I'm pretty sure they ripped it when it broke.