I've worn them several times, not only in the water but also when climbing smooth rocks. It definitely keeps my feet from stepping on rocks, gravel, buried fish hooks, glass, etc that might be in the water. They fit well, don't fill up with water like old neoprene shoes, and offer pretty good traction. I don't see anything falling apart (yet. Let's hope it doesn't fall apart) and I'm happy with the purchase. Very good shoes for your money.