Review on 🚬 Portable Ashtray Set of 2 - Car Cigarette Ash Bucket Extinguisher Butt Holder for Smoking, Ideal Smoking Accessory for Auto, Truck, Home, Office, Beach - Black by Marlo Schlachter

As many other reviewers have said, the lid is very flimsy and won't screw down. Other than that, it's a cheap ashtray on Amazon so they absolutely do the job. I wouldn't recommend them for a car or anywhere you're worried about the cover coming off, but they'll work fine for my purpose. I was looking for cheap cup shaped ashtrays for my golf cart and for my pool and they were absolutely perfect. I bought a more expensive version with higher ratings for my car but for a cheap ashtray they are ok. 3 stars because it is!