Review on FOXHACKLE Pocket Leather Minimalist Handmade by Cory Mosley

I bought this minimalistic wallet for my husband so he doesn't have to carry his big wallet around just to go to the nearest store or for a walk. However, it was so disappointing when I received the wallet. He was already scratched. (1st photo). I'm wondering if the seller sent me a previously returned product and is hoping I'll just keep it? Despite this, I decided to return it and ask for another replacement. So the seller sent a replacement the next day (I was impressed with the speed of delivery). When I opened the Revain envelope, the first thing I noticed was that the packaging was different from my 1st order. Then I compared side by side, it looks like the first ones got harder after replacement (4 photos). The replacement also failed, there are some marks on the surface (last photo). but i decided to keep this one because my husband loves it thin and simple.