I lugged about an Xbox and a Sony controller simultaneously. Heaven and earth meet here. The Xbox has its own share of quality problems, but they are manageable and don't ruin the gaming experience. The Xbox controller is optimal for playing any game, including MK11. The Xbox controller is superior to the PlayStation controller in terms of comfort in the hands, quality of materials, and quality of vibration. Separately, I observe that the gamepad comes in a plain, unimpressive container and is not packed extremely snugly (it dangles a little in it). Further quibbling. Xbox is preferable, but, if you're looking for a "wow effect" when giving away the gamepad. Those who prefer playing on a personal computer have no need for this joystick.