At first I thought there were only 11 of the largest nails (1-5/8") in the box but it looks like they packaged them oddly so in a minute large nails was packed in the bottom two squares of the box, and there were only 11 of those nails in the bottom right square. Since the package was a mess, I also have a feeling the small nails are probably a mess, but I'm not going to go through them to find out, although I wish there were more larger nails as I need them more than smaller nails.