I bought a size 0-2 for my 3 year old daughter (she wears 3t/4t clothes) and they fit perfectly with room to grow so I would definitely recommend going down a size.
However, we're very happy with it - her hands stayed warm and dry even when snow got into her boots and everywhere else.
Assorted Toddler Winter Mittens for Girls' Accessories
42 Review
Outdoors Girls' Dustproof Multifunctional Headband Balaclava - Versatile Accessories
43 Review
Toasty-Dry Insulated Waterproof Mittens for Toddlers & Kids by JAN & JUL
42 Review
Miaowoof Toddler Waterproof Thinsulate Mittens Girls' Accessories for Cold Weather
52 Review
Girls' Fleece Collar Warmer - Winter Autumn Accessories and Fashion Scarves
26 Review
Stay Cozy and Stylish with HappyTree Fashion Knitted Winter Infinity Girls' Accessories
33 Review
Bazzle Baby BandoBib: Stylish and Adjustable Girls' Accessory with Double Layers
34 Review
Stylish and Reusable Washable Balaclava: Perfect Fashion Scarf Accessory for Girls
24 Review