5'9" 185 lbs, plus small I really think you'll be fine as long as you stick to what you normally get. The sleeve length from XL fits me but I'm afraid they'll be too short if I go to medium or L for the price not worth sending back so I'll order a smaller size and see what happens.
Newzill Compression Calf Sleeves (20-30MmHg) For Men And Women - Ideal Alternative To Compression Socks, Perfect For Running, Shin Splints, Medical Needs, Travel, And Nursing
42 Review
Optimized Airflux Sleeve for PGA TOUR Standards
43 Review
Carhartt Crewneck Sweatshirt Regular X Large
42 Review
Bodybuilding Pack Workout Shirt from COOFANDY
46 Review