5'9" 185 lbs, plus small I really think you'll be fine as long as you stick to what you normally get. The sleeve length from XL fits me but I'm afraid they'll be too short if I go to medium or L for the price not worth sending back so I'll order a smaller size and see what happens.
Gildan Performance Men's 👕 Clothing and Shirts with Moisture-Wicking Polyester
44 Review
H2H Mens Casual Slim Fit Short Sleeve T-Shirts Cotton Blended Soft Lightweight V-Neck/Crew-Neck
46 Review
Van Heusen Traveler Stretch Men's Shirt
47 Review
Men'S Long Sleeve Polo Shirt - Slim Fit, Stretchy, Breathable Collar
43 Review
Newzill Compression Calf Sleeves (20-30MmHg) For Men And Women - Ideal Alternative To Compression Socks, Perfect For Running, Shin Splints, Medical Needs, Travel, And Nursing
42 Review
Crewneck Fleece Sweatshirt For Men By Goodthreads
48 Review
Bodybuilding Pack Workout Shirt from COOFANDY
46 Review
Optimized Airflux Sleeve for PGA TOUR Standards
43 Review