My previous plastic mop/broom holder was in good condition so I bought this one as it's metal and I hope it will last longer. I chose to install with screws because I don't think the glue will last as long in an uninsulated garage. So far this is working fine. It easily holds brooms, dust mop and wet mop. The compression straps are much stronger than the ones in my previous set. I think this one will stay with me for a long time.