I ordered a belt that fits my actual pant size and it actually fits quite well (the third hole is fine, there's room to grow!). The material feels like plastic in the hand, but looks quite nice visually. I know it's leather, I don't doubt it, it just seems more pliable to me than other smooth leather straps I've had. It's nice and wide, which is great for people who carry a spare tire. If the belt holds up over time I will upgrade to 5 stars later.