Non-Spill Replacement Caps: Magicfour Water Bottle Caps For 3 & 5 Gallon Water Jugs Review

These water jug caps fit perfectly for my 5 gallon jugs from sparkletts company. I was looking for reusable caps for my jugs since i cancelled my subscription service with sparkletts and there bottles no longer come with reusable caps and these are the perfect fit for the jugs. I love that they come with the inside clear cap that works perfect with my water machine.

I got 2/5 good ones. 2 caps seal really good but the rest don't they keep leaking. I keep my 5gallons sideways I hope I hear back from the vendor to resolve this.

They have to he cut down to be removable. Not worth the price for something that has to be modified in order to work. Wont buy them again.

I really wish I'd read the reviews before I bought these. Once they are put on the bottles they do not come off again! I got them because I also bought a stand to hold my water jugs and wanted to be able to have the bottles sealed tight as they lay on the side on the stand. So when I refilled the 5 gallon jugs I had to fill them through the little hole in the middle but since the tiny cap that actually seals the lid is on the inside, I couldn't seal them properly. So when I placed them on the…

I love the bargain for the amount of caps you get, seals tight and simple to use. My only problem is needing to peel off the bottom edges to get it off.

While they're advertised as being reusable, they don't actually come off easily enough to be reusable. Neither I nor either of my roommates could get them off without cutting them apart, and even if we could, the plastic feels so fragile compared to how tightly they're attached that I think pulling them off would tear them anyway. As single-use caps, they're both too expensive and too inconvenient.

Not reusable! It was beyond hard to take these caps off to refill the 5gallons.I ended up cutting the cap.My water dispenser is a bottom load so the caps really need to be off to load.These caps did not do the job it was intended for.

They are designed for my water cooler bottles they don’t fit on snug at all they fall off easy. If the empty bottle has a lid on it in the backseat of the car and it falls over the lid will fall off enroll under the front seat. I’m afraid to transport water with the lid being so loose I have to secure the bottles in car with heavy objects bracing full bottle in fear cap will fly off.

They did not fit into my 5 gallon water containers. I have primo and sparklet water jugs. These did not fit even though it stated 55mm. I am disappointed. My grandkids enjoy playing with them.

I should have read my reviews on the item. These things are almost impossible to takeoff. I figured I would be able to reuse these but you are not able to. These are a one time use thing.

I purchased these caps so the water wouldn’t spill in my vehicle when they tumble over when making a turn. Don’t get me wrong, they’ll do the trick, but good luck getting them off once you’ve put them on. We had to cut every single one of them just to remove them from the water jug, which means they aren’t reusable!

Works really well! Had a water cooler that started to leak so we bought a portable one, needed these to set the portable thing on as our other covers had been opened.

Will not work with my water dispenser, the cap will not fit in opening. It's too small. I had to remove it for it to go in. These caps are hard to put on and off and the stopper leaks..

I really like these caps. I lost the ones i used and needed new ones. These are reusable and are pretty thick. One thing i hate about these is you cant really just pull the tab to peel. Theres no cutout so i had to get a box cutter so i can remove it and reattach

Not what I imagined it to be. I wanted a cap where I can put it on and off. Once you put it on. It is almost impossible pulling it off by hand. You need a knife or a pair of scissors. Def won’t recommend this product.

These are not reusable! I wish I would’ve looked at reviews prior to buying. These things are so hard to get off. They’ll be going in the garbage.

Cap went on easily, but taking it off to refill the bottle requires pliers. which will likely tear the cap eventually.Otherwise, the cap holds water as designed.

The caps did not fit right on my bottles once I was able to get it on my machine the caps would get stuck when I would take it off

Easy to use and reuse. Pull off and pop on and the center hole has a resealable cap that’s attached for easy under dispenser use. Very happy with my purchase.

These are terrible. They fit great and snug, but you can’t take them off without stretching and damaging the pull tab. In some cases the pull tab rips off completely. They are not reusable. Basically get damaged after the first use. Waste of money.