Almost perfect. I would have liked about 1/8" more clearance for jumbo toilet paper rolls, but it looks good and does the job. Super easy to install. I've seen a few reviews commenting on it not sticking to the wall very well. If you put anything like double-stick tape on a painted sheetrock wall, and then apply lateral pressure to it, like tearing off toilet paper, it WILL eventually tear off the wall. If your wall is a typical sheetrock wall, use a screw-on TP holder. Fixtures like this one stSee full review