I've tried sooo many makeup removers specifically for waterproof/long-wearing eye makeup, but NOTHING beats this one! You simply apply about a quarter of the product to a tissue, hold it over your eye for about 5 seconds, and then wipe your finger over it! No friction or repeated scrubbing and scraping. The skin around the eyes is so sensitive that the last thing you need to do is clean your eyes! This product is amazing and the only one I will ever use to remove eye makeup. By the way, I've already bought it from Ulta and it also gets cloudy when it's shaken a lot. This is not a sign of a fraudulent product! What you are seeing are very, very small droplets of oil suspended in a water element of liquid. It should look like this. Trust me, this product on this list is legit and worth every penny!
Nivea Caring Eye Make-Up Remover Sensitive 125ml: Gentle & Effective Cleansing for Delicate Skin
14 Review
🌿 JUNO & Co. Clean 10 Cleansing Balm - Natural 10 Ingredient Makeup Remover 85g / 3.0oz
9 Review
🧼 Dr.Jart Dermaclear Micro pH Foam Deep Cleansing Gel: Ultimate Skin Purification with 120 ml of Pure Refreshment
15 Review
Eau Thermale Avene Micellar Lotion: Cleansing Water, Toning Solution, and Makeup Remover, Ideal for All Skin Types in One Product
14 Review
🏨 Bioderma Atoderm Cleansing Oil: Ultimate Solution for Very Dry Sensitive Skin
39 Review
Hempz Exotic Natural Herbal Body Moisturizer With Pure Hemp Seed Oil, Green Tea And Asian Pear, 2.25 Fluid Ounce - Nourishing Vegan Skin Lotion For Dryness And Flaking With Acai And Goji Berry
42 Review
Smooth Skin With SOL DE JANEIRO Brazilian Bum Bum Cream
34 Review
Triclosan-Free Clear Liquid Hand Soap Refill, 56 Fluid Ounces, 2-Pack By Amazon Basics - Gentle And Mild
43 Review