I ordered these after receiving a set of joysticks/tools from a competitor and realizing that the joysticks they provided were complete rubbish. Their ribbon cables were too big and broke when I tried to "force" them into place. The other had the same problem but also had a sticky residue on it. These spares were ordered after them and they were much better. They looked almost exactly like the factory sticks I was going to replace and the cables fitted perfectly. I didn't look for a second replacement as I only had to replace one stick (broken in a fall, no slipping issue) but even if it didn't I feel like I got my money's worth as they have a little have been depreciated over time. Purchases. Docked one star only because the packaging was a plastic bag and not the hard plastic box which the other (albeit junk quality) joycons I ordered arrived first.