Review on Bomea Cell Phone Holster - Belt Case for Samsung Galaxy S20, S10, S9, S8 (Not Plus Model) - Black by Alex Rea

My phone is Galaxy J3 and same size as S6/S7. With the Otterbox Commuter Case it will not fit in this holster! I mean, I can slide it in with some effort, but the flip cover barely stays closed and randomly pops open with a little jerk because it's not big enough to fully cover my protruding phone. When I put a couple of credit cards in the ID card holder, it doesn't close at all. My wife has a Galaxy J1 with a screen of only 4.5 inches and this case barely fits her phone with a case similar to the Otterbox case. I don't know why the manufacturer couldn't make this holster a little bigger, but I can't use it on my 5 inch Galaxy J3 that I gave my wife. I ordered this Samsung Galaxy S3, S4 and HTC One Large Size Case, Smartphone Case with Belt Loop, 5.75 x 3 x .75 Belt Clip and this one does not have an ID/card holder but it fits my phone with Otterbox Suitcase because it's a bit bigger.