This jacket is pretty much what I expected. I got xxl and I wear a womans large and it fits comfortably, an xl would probably be too snug. It is very reflective and the lining is comfortable.The downsides are that its not breathable (but no jacket with this material would be) and the pockets and hood are shallow.The positives are that it works as stated and is constructed well. I get irritated by some clothing materials and this jacket is fine with me. I would recommend this jacket.