Had these for 2 months now. I have been rotating between a pair of Merrells and these. I occasionally work in a wash bay. This boot is more water resistant by far. Sometimes I put Miles of concrete walking in. These shoes leave my feet less fatigued. The materials and the cuts are not as refined as Merrell. But the are more water resistant, and give better cushion. I am sure they won't hold up as long either. But at 60 dollars every 3 to 6 months they are a better value, considering you will be dryer and more comfortable.