I really like these boots. I haven’t had a chance to truly test them out, but they are comfortable, seem to be sufficiently warm and water proof and look nice. I believe the fit is true to size, that being said, I returned the first pair I ordered for a half size larger, just for a bit more room around the toe box. The 8’s I originally ordered wouldn’t have been roomy enough to my liking if I decided to wear thicker socks. The 8 1/2’s that I eventually received instead felt much better.