Review on Fluoride-Free Whitening Toothpaste with Activated CharcoalExtreme (1-Pack) by Ankur Songz

Found on a dollar tree, loved it. Then I couldn't find it anymore. For my sister I told her how cool the product is. Well I ordered this from one seller and one for myself from another seller. We somehow didn't have both hoses that had air in them. I also ordered 4 more tubes from another seller at a lower price. I haven't checked them yet. I didn't ask her the taste but mine is slightly minty as opposed to the dollar tree. It immediately turned very white and was very minty. I don't know if it whitens my sister's teeth. However, we both found it wasn't as messy as other brands of charcoal. One in particular was very dirty, and it wasn't a powder, but a tube like that. She likes this brand better, but I don't like mine. Feel something is wrong. I have some left over from the $1 tube and compared them. It is a pity that with such a high price the quality of the same product can vary.