I usually wear a 9 for loafers, 9.5 for slippers and prefer W to M. I have 9.5 M and it fits very well. A little tight but not stuffy. Keep in mind that sizes vary from model to model, even within the same Rockport brand. I also have Modern Prep 9W moccasins but it's HUGE.
Bostonian Bolton Loafer: Sleek Leather Shoes for Men
48 Review
Wool Blend Slippers Heathered Leather Maximum Men's Shoes and Loafers & Slip-Ons
58 Review
Men's Merrell Jungle Waterproof Slip-On Loafers in Gunsmoke - Shoes for Superior Comfort and Style
47 Review
53534 Titan Safety Toe Men's Shoes by Timberland PRO
46 Review