I saw bad reviews on other joysticks and decided on these as they seemed the closest to the OEM parts you'll find here. Replaced the stick and they feel perfect. Feels the same as the original stick, if not very close, there were no issues with size, and the inclusion of three extra screws was a nice touch as they proved spirited. Will update in a few weeks to make sure they don't let me down, if not I have up to 5 stars. But so far first impressions are good.