Reviews and answers to questions indicate that people receive different versions of this product. Some state an overall height of 4 3/4 inches and others say 5 inches. Well I took a chance and ordered (11-12-21) and got the 5" tall version. This is taller than needed. This gives more "headroom" than the cards need and makes the liner taller than my current wallet and the new wallet that I recently ordered. The insert sticks out above and/or below the leather case. It just bulges a bit so I could 'technically' use it, but that will certainly cause the Liner wears out prematurely, and it's very frustrating that it doesn't fit properly. Seems like a 4 3/4" version would be perfect. I hate returning them because they were so cheap but I will still buy another brand and hope to get something to use.