I've never used Silpat so I can't compare the two but they are great for cutting out cookies. Non-stick, minimizes smearing, super easy cleaning. My only issue and the reason I gave it 4 stars and not 5 is the size. I have Nordicware 1/2 leaf cutters, this mat is slightly wider to fit the floor perfectly. Maybe the pans are to blame and they would be better in a different brand of tray. They're a game changer anyway, I've used parchment paper while battling some recipes that were still circulating more than I'd like. I haven't had any more problems since the purchase.
100-Pack Of Disposable 18-Inch Piping Bags For Cake, Cupcake, And Cookie Decorating - Perfect For Icing And Frosting!
41 Review
PME Scriber Needle Modelling Tool, For Cake Decorating, 5.7-Inch
38 Review
4 Pack 12 Inch Stainless Steel Round Pizza Baking Pan Tray Crisper Sheet Oven Cooking Healthy For Pizzas - Deedro
47 Review
AmazonBasics Silicone Baking Mat Sheet
48 Review