Bought as a birthday gift. I can't give this controller a clear rating other than that it looks amazing. This is the first Xbox One controller I've touched and I'm amazed at how people can play when the d-pad is a full button. That being said, I'm impressed with the Xbox controller improvements. It's a bit thinner, but the extra weight is kind of reassuring. I didn't notice any lag between the button and the screen and it's ready to use, unlike the PS controller which required a third-party program.