
I bought this in store and loved the color so much that I came home and ordered another one online. It ran out after 4 uses so I started using the one I bought on Amazon. After 4 uses it was gone. I opened the plastic to see if the pencil had fallen in or broken, but it didn't. Either I was really unlucky, or this product is defective.

L "Oreal Paris Mascara Volume Million Lashes Feline Noir, extra black
39 Review

Maybelline New York Mascara The Falsies Lash Lift, black
94 Review

π Vivienne SabΓ³ Cabaret PremiΓ¨re Waterproof Mascara - Artistic Volume with No Clump, Cruelty-Free, 0.3 fl. oz.
71 Review

NYX professional makeup Palette of shadows Ultimate Shadow Palette Festival 13
42 Review

Unleash Your Inner Unicorn With KARIZMA'S Chunky Holographic Glitter Set - Perfect For Festivals, Raves And Makeup Artistry!
35 Review

Neem And Tea Tree Oil Balm - Soothes And Calms Dry, Itchy Skin Irritation - Oleavine TheraTree
36 Review

Vitamin C Moisturizer By The Body Shop - 1.7 Oz Boost For Brighter, Healthier Skin
34 Review

Cuccio Naturale Milk And Honey Hydrating Dry Body Oil With Rich Butter Blend
32 Review