Turns out I didn't need 2x2GB because there was one free slot (which is unusual for most laptops), but 1x2GB would do. However, I'm glad I have a matching dual channel performance kit that I've read will work in this old MacBook with two SODIMMs installed.
π₯οΈ Helifouner 450-Piece Computer Standoffs Spacer Screws Kit: Ideal for Hard Drive, Motherboard, Fan, Power Graphics & Computer Cases
10 Review
Glarks 660 Pieces Phillips Assortment Motherboard
10 Review
MacBook Retina 13-inch (A1425, A1502) and π© 15-inch (A1398) Bottom Case Screw Set with Pentalobe Screwdriver
11 Review
36-Pack Black Rubber PC CPU/Case Fan Screws/Rivets Set for Computer
11 Review