Most reviews are correct. For my wide feet, this shoe is VERY comfortable, especially compared to all the other shoes I've worn in the past. And yes, if you wear 9Wide, you'll get a 9 in this shoe. I got the 9 1/2 "just in case" (didn't want to bother with shipping it back for an exchange) and it's a bit bigger than I really need. But there's nothing a thick sock won't take care of. Better a little too long than too tight. Overall a great shoe for people with wide feet.