I love these shoes and have bought them twice but I am giving them three stars because of the smell they capture. Not wanting to be rude, my feet never smell in shoes (whether I'm wearing socks or not) unless they're sneakers, of course. However, they always seem to give off an unpleasant foot odor. It's a shame, because I like the look. When you buy them, you get a pack of Scent Eaters.