Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
survive the desert with gamewright's forbidden desert: a cooperative strategy board game logo

Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game Review

12

·

Very good

Revainrating 4.5 out of 5  
Rating 
4.7
🎮 Kids' Plug & Play Video Games, 👶 Kids' Electronics

View on AmazonView on ЯM

Media

(4)
img 1 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 2 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 3 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 4 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game

Photos by authors

(7)
img 5 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 6 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 7 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game
img 8 attached to Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game

Details

BrandGamewright
MaterialPaper
ThemeScience Fiction
GenreStrategy
Number of Players5

Description of Survive The Desert With Gamewright'S Forbidden Desert: A Cooperative Strategy Board Game

Thirst for Survival. 2 to 5 players. Playing time: 45 minutes. Playing instructions included. Ages 10 and up

Reviews

Global ratings 12
  • 5
    8
  • 4
    4
  • 3
    0
  • 2
    0
  • 1
    0

Type of review

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Forbidden Desert does not desert its predecessor.

I was first introduced to Forbidden Island when playing a friend's copy and found it to be a fun game with some unique mechanics. When I learned about Forbidden Desert I figured this would be similar but was surprised at the added twists this game has. It still relies on cooperation (though in my experience it seems like games tend to gravitate towards an overall "leader") but now literally adds the new layer of sand.It's a challenging game with replayability (winning is not easy and…

Pros
  • Board Games
Cons
  • The game's pieces can be quite fragile and prone to breaking if mishandled, which can be frustrating for players who have invested in the game

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Another Awesome Adventure For the Whole Family!

I'm a big fan of the "Pandemic Light" game of Forbidden Island. It's a beautiful game that fun to play and helps people like how cooperative board games are played. Coming off my high from Forbidden Island I snatched up the sequel game Forbidden Desert. After purchasing it I realized it might be a mistake. Why have two slightly different versions of the same game? It sat on my shelf for a long time. I kept meaning to play it but never got around to it. Until now.This game may be similar

Pros
  • Great board game, enjoyed it !!
Cons
  • The game can be quite time-consuming, as it can take several hours to complete a single round

Revainrating 5 out of 5

A More Evolved Game

My gaming group enjoys cooperative board games and we often play games like Pandemic. The only problem is that occasionally due to chance, the game ends in defeat very early and suddenly just with the flop of a bad card or two. We've lost games before the third cycle of turns begins. Forbidden Desert changes that up. Like Pandemic and other games of its ilk, there are several ways to lose (3 in fact; run out of sand tiles, the storm picks up to the skull marker, or any player dies of thirst)…

Pros
  • 10 - 15 years
Cons
  • The game can get repetitive after several plays, leading to boredom and disinterest among players

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Fun sequel! on my review.

OVERVIEWForbidden Island is the game that really got me into cooperative games and modern board games in general. Pandemic is my favorite game. Both of these are by Matt Leacock, so when his new title Forbidden Desert was announced, I could not wait to get my hands on it! I was a little worried it might be an unnecessary purchase for someone who already owns Forbidden Island, but I couldn't pass it up. Luckily, my fears were unfounded - although it scratches the same itch as Forbidden Island…

Pros
  • Playing instructions included
Cons
  • The game is quite expensive compared to other board games on the market, making it not accessible to many people on a tight budget

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Good game, but only if you modify the rules to suit you

I like this game. It's much harder than Forbidden Island, as the rules are defined. In order to make Forbidden Desert playable, you have to modify the rules. Otherwise, you pretty much always lose. What fun is a game that you *always* lose? Some of our changed rules include (mix and match these rules for interesting play variations):1) Picking up the "part" (as 1 action) on the first "part" tile of its kind that you excavate. This leads to a short game of about 20 minutes.2)…

Pros
  • Ages 10 and up
Cons
  • The game requires a lot of table space, which may not be convenient for players with limited room in their homes

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Very Fun, Very Challenging Game

At Settlers of Catan game night last month, some friends brought over Forbidden Island and we tried it out and it was a blast! (We love Catan, but sometimes we need a break in the form of a co-op game - too many tempers could flare up, if you know what I mean!) I looked on Best Buy to buy Island and saw this sequel and decided to try this one instead and I am very satisfied with this decision!-In Island, you lose tiles as they flood, while in Desert you have sand build up on tiles. In Island…

Pros
  • I bought it for my son. He’s happy with it.
Cons
  • The game is quite complicated and may be difficult to understand for some players, leading to frustration during play

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Great game with one small issue.

Positives of the game:1. Easy to learn. You will have the rules figured out in about 15 minutes. Less if you have played "Forbidden Island". This is a strong plus if you are playing the game with new people to the group or if you are playing with younger players.2. Easy to play. Play your four actions, draw cards for the storm, play passes to the next player. Easy enough.3. Very challenging. In my experience with co-op games, I want to play something that is fairly challenging to beat (in some…

Pros
  • 415
Cons
  • The game's theme may not appeal to everyone, as not everyone enjoys desert survival scenarios

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Moving Board on my review.

It’s pretty fun but kind of boring after a while. I’ve only played with myself and my wife. We can win on novice every time. It’s probably more fun with more people but once you know the game it seems pretty easy.

Pros
  • Toys & Games
Cons
  • The game's rules may be difficult to remember for players who only play infrequently, leading to confusion and frustration during play

I think some of the reviews differ on this game because the experience is very different depending on the number of players. I will get to that in the minute.If you like Forbidden island and Pandemic, this may be the game for you. It has elements from both games. I like how you are not just pretending to build the ship as you play. You have a little boat and parts to equip it with. It seems more complicated than it is. The rule book is pretty clear on how you are supposed to play. Once you have

Pros
  • Playing time: 45 minutes
Cons
  • The game may not be suitable for large groups, as it can be difficult to keep everyone engaged and involved in the gameplay

Revainrating 5 out of 5

An Excellent Game best in my review

This is another masterpiece from Matt Leacock.It is a little more complex, and a tiny bit harder to learn, than his previous game in the series, Forbidden Island. Which, by the way, is just as excellent.This game is easy to set up and infinitely re-playable. A superb value for the money.

Pros
  • 0.01 ounces
Cons
  • The game relies heavily on luck rather than strategy, which may be frustrating for players who prefer a more skill-based game

Revainrating 4 out of 5

Buy Island, then Desert

TLDR: The 4-stars is for the comparison to Forbidden Island. Buy Island first. If you enjoy that and want more variety, then buy Desert.Forbidden Desert is the stand-alone spiritual successor to Forbidden Island.Desert is an action-based, ability-focused cooperative game. You move around the map (created by placing the desert squares), digging through sand, excavating tiles to discover directions to the treasure (or nothing at all!), and making sure you have enough water to survive the heat…

Pros
  • August 5, 2013
Cons
  • The game's cooperative nature may not appeal to players who prefer a more competitive game experience

Revainrating 5 out of 5

Great game, directions a bit hard to ingest

The game play is easy, fun and dynamic, once you get started. The directions are well written, but a lot to ingest for how simple the game play actually is. I love how every-time you play, the scenario is a bit different, and that you can play it with just two people if you want. I play it often and have yet to get bored of it. I just purchased other games from Gamewright because I love this one so much!

Pros
  • Games & Accessories
Cons
  • The game may not be suitable for players who have mobility or dexterity issues, as it requires a lot of manipulation of game pieces and cards