We've had a lot of the yellow tuffy bones and they've always lasted a while. Maybe there's a difference because this blue one lasted for less than a day before it started falling apart

I have three dogs that play and chew on this toy daily. One of the dog’s it a pitty who destroys most toys very quickly. A friend gave me this toy over a year ago and I has outlasted any other toy I’ve ever bought. Most toys get destroyed within hours, but not this one. That is why I bought two more so each dog can have one. Definitely worth buying.