I purchased these shoes as an Easter gift for my granddaughter. She loved them They fit perfectly, not tight around the toes at all. I can't really rate the other comments you ask for because my granddaughter doesn't live near me. My comments are based on what my daughter has told me.
Flexible Comfort: pediped Flex Isabella Mary Jane for Toddlers and Little Kids
47 Review
Felix Flora Toddler Flower Dress Shoes - Adorable and Comfy Flats
47 Review
Stylish and Comfortable pediped Flex Estella Mary Jane Shoes for Toddlers and Little Kids
60 Review
Slip-Resistant Crib Shoes for Babies: Robeez Soft Soles for Girls and Unisex Toddlers, Ages 0-24 Months
53 Review
ALEADER Walking Sneakers Lightweight Purple Girls' Shoes and Athletic
52 Review
Diadora Cattura Soccer Cleats Toddler Girls' Shoes for Athletic
56 Review
Breathable Fashion Sneakers for Baby & Toddler Boys & Girls: Bless Children Walking & Running Shoes
54 Review
New Balance Reveal Running Little Girls' Shoes and Athletic
56 Review