I bought them for a trip to Hawaii in early February. I swam in it, did muddy and non-muddy hikes, kayaking, and other activities. They surprised me how comfortable they are. I would definitely buy them again.
Pros
These water shoes are amazing, love them. I wear them at the lake and in the yard. So comfortable.
Cons
Shoes may not breathe enough, leading to foot odor and discomfort.