I would give the shoe a 5 because it looks very nice. I like the material it's made of, not the traditional mesh fabric. It would be easy to keep looking good. The only downside is that they are too small, although I ordered half a size larger than I usually wear. I usually wear a 10, but only a 10 1/2 was available in this color. I thought it might be too big but it was quite the opposite. The return process went smoothly. I have reordered a size larger.