The vinyl case was good but the metal used in the actual tools was too soft and malleable to use. On the first attempt to lift the spare tire into place, the square end of the road that mates with the tire lifter rounded and failed to engage the mechanism. I tried another rod with the same result. I still had the factory rod that came with the truck. It's noticeably thicker and reinforced where that aftermarket rounds out. Qualitatively not comparable, I do not recommend this kit. You can useโฆ