Works fine as usual. Good value for money, matching buttonholes are better seen, pair is slightly oversized. So far the durability has been satisfactory.

Great thick fabric - keeps the cool breeze out but still not too hot on warm days - ordered for an older (70+) man who loves them and will wear them every day!

I ordered a size up as some similar shirts run smaller but I was surprised it was the right size so don't be surprised. Quality, definitely durable material so not a lot of creases but it will stand up to abuse. The weird thing is that I don't have any hidden buttonholes on the buttonless collar and there is an extra piece of fabric that I have no idea about. Although I definitely recommend it

Very good quality and style, I especially like the collar. The shirt turned out a lot better than I expected. he looks great on me I usually buy shirts in a large size, but the medium one fits very well.

this is a heavy shirt. Suitable for general outdoor use. seems well done. I use it over a long sleeve t-shirt in cooler weather, worn as an overshirt without tucking in. Came a little more than ordered, but that's ok.

The price-performance ratio is very good, the shirt fits well and is true to size. The Madewell shirt is perfect for all day work. It's a bit stiff and hopefully it will soften up with more washes, otherwise it's a great shirt.

Shirt made of very thick, heavy and stiff material. But the real problem is the size, I ordered 4X and it looks more like a 7 or 8X, seriously. I wouldn't even know what size to get if I had to reorder. "Maybe" 2x bigger but I'm afraid it might be too big but maybe too small too. You don't want to make two returns and maybe get the right size on the third try, so just return it and give up.

I like the material and the shirt feels comfortable. The shirt seems durable and as mentioned in other comments I've seen here the size is a little big. I'm preparing to place another order for a khaki shirt, but this time it will be a medium size, not a large.

I am 6ft 3in, chest 42in and weigh 185. I have ordered a large, The label on the bag was large, but the middle one was inside. I decided to try it, everything is fine. The length was ok, maybe a little short but to be expected. It was too tight on the shoulders, but a little too big on the upper body. As another reviewer noted, "odd proportions". This time I chose Big Long. If the torso is the same size, then everything will probably be fine. I will check this size as soon as it becomes…