
I've been using the Simple Eye Makeup Remover for years because it works and isn't as harsh as some I've tried in the past. Can't find it in stores anymore but found it on Amazon which was interesting. The last few bottles I bought were in the old, smaller packaging (I've attached the picture) and I had no problems. 4 bottles ordered and received in new/different packaging. The formula has a different feel (slightly less greasy) and it stung my eyes! My eyes were so red after using it that I could hardly keep them open. Doesn't seem really safe and I won't be using it again. Now I have 4 bottles and the return period has already expired :/

E.L.F. Makeup Remover Pen Clear, 1 Count
15 Review

π Color Salute Safari OK Beauty Tint for Lips and Cheeks
13 Review

πΏ JUNO & Co. Clean 10 Cleansing Balm - Natural 10 Ingredient Makeup Remover 85g / 3.0oz
9 Review

Nivea Caring Eye Make-Up Remover Sensitive 125ml: Gentle & Effective Cleansing for Delicate Skin
14 Review

Hempz Exotic Natural Herbal Body Moisturizer With Pure Hemp Seed Oil, Green Tea And Asian Pear, 2.25 Fluid Ounce - Nourishing Vegan Skin Lotion For Dryness And Flaking With Acai And Goji Berry
42 Review

Unleash Your Inner Unicorn With KARIZMA'S Chunky Holographic Glitter Set - Perfect For Festivals, Raves And Makeup Artistry!
35 Review

Neem And Tea Tree Oil Balm - Soothes And Calms Dry, Itchy Skin Irritation - Oleavine TheraTree
36 Review

π¨ Bioderma Atoderm Cleansing Oil: Ultimate Solution for Very Dry Sensitive Skin
39 Review