I give it 2 stars simply because the box was intact and the shelves had creases which I had to hammer out myself to hang them properly. As you can see from the photos. I don't know if they just didn't bother with their packaging because I would say they are easy to spot. Anyone in quality could see that there is a curve where there shouldn't be. Lol for $260 + tax you expect it to be perfect and undamaged. BUT in general the assembly, installation of two shelves went smoothly and very aesthetically. However, I removed their logo stickers because I think they look better than the regular ones.